fox: hello gorgeous (vanity: my left eye is not normally purple) (pride)
fox ([personal profile] fox) wrote2006-05-04 07:05 pm

do other people do this?  [wow, that got ramblier than i intended.]

Sometimes I make an effort to look around and see if I can see people approximately my size, so I can see how they dress.  This is not for scoffing-at-them purposes, although that's sometimes what happens; it's for getting-ideas purposes, because I can't see a window display and have the first idea whether the outfit advertised would suit me or not.  (Okay, I can have the first idea, which is probably not.  But I can't get accurate specific reads from mannequins, is what I'm saying.)  Do people do that?  And then the trouble with this practice is, one, it's very difficult for me to tell if another woman is approximately my size or not.  I can easily identify people who are very large or very small or even sort of normal medium-sized, but among the people who are on the small side of large, or on the large side of regular, I have a really hard time.

We're supposed to be everywhere -- we keep reading that the average American woman [granted, I'm not in the USA now, but I have the same trouble when I am] is a size 14; I'd be a size 15, if such a thing existed, I'm 16-with-a-belt, and I can't see my fellow sufferers anywhere.  It must be that when they say "the average American woman is a size 14" they mean "the average size worn by American women is 14", which is quite a different thing.  A sample group in which half the women were size 8 or below and the other half were size 20 or above would yield an average around 14, without a single actual size 14 in it.

Anyway, it's hard for me to identify people my size on sight.  Sometimes I think of myself as smaller than I turn out to be -- notably, when I see pictures of myself and think, My god, I don't remember being that size on that day (because the other people in the pictures look the size I remember them looking, so one is forced to conclude that the picture is accurate).  But other times, I've been aware that I think of myself as bigger than I turn out to be.  Anecdote:  one time The Boy Who and I were walking someplace, and I had to ask him to slow down because I was having a hard time keeping up with him, especially in my three-inch heels.  He apologized and tried to walk slower, and I said something about how it's not quite fair that heels make a person taller but don't lengthen her stride.  (In fact of course they shorten the stride a bit.)  Not, though, I said, that even if the extra three inches were in my leg rather than strapped to my foot, they'd have made much of a difference in the area of keeping up, because he'd still have been nine inches taller than me. -- But before I could get to "you'd still be nine inches taller", he'd said "Well, right, because I'm just bigger than you."  [/anecdote]  I remember being surprised to hear that -- because it's true that he's a foot taller than me, but he's fairly athletic and lean.  I suppose I had tended to think of myself as being a woman of, say, 5'10", but only having 5'4" of vertical space to work with.*  So the horizontal dimensions had to, you know, compensate.  But thinking about it, you know, I guess I know that (for example) my brother is bigger than me, because I know when I buy men's shirts and sweaters I buy them at least a size smaller than he does.  (And I've got this chest!  -- Things fit me differently in the chest than they fit him, obviously, but even taking that into account, the things are a size smaller.)  And I know The Boy Who is about my brother's size, maybe a little bigger.  So, transitively, he must be bigger than me.  How strange, for a person who is accustomed to thinking of herself as Bigger Than Other People, to say nothing of seeing those pictures mentioned above, to have that sort of realization.



*This is another thing.  If I do see people who I feel like might be about my size, they're invariably at least four inches taller than I am, so I can't take style cues from them anyhow.

[identity profile] asphodeline.livejournal.com 2006-05-04 06:13 pm (UTC)(link)
I do the same!! I've also become increasingly bold and started actually asking people where they get their clothes from if I really like them! I've never had anyone refuse to tell me!

Catalogues and sop window mannequins are no use in any case - mostly in the windows the clothes are pinned and tucked up and very misleading!

[identity profile] neotoma.livejournal.com 2006-05-04 06:14 pm (UTC)(link)
Plus, there is that whole long-waisted/short-waisted thing that screws up the fit of shirts and dresses.

[identity profile] sharp-tongue.livejournal.com 2006-05-04 06:52 pm (UTC)(link)
I know about you mean about the disconnect between your mental body image and your 'real' body image. I know that I'm quite short (5'0") but it never really struck me until I was in a martial arts class standing next to my brother and watching sparring. I looked past them at the wall of mirrors and saw the height differential clearly. I was aghast. Granted, my brother is 6'0", but it was shocking to see that the top of my head didn't even come to his chin.

[identity profile] darthfox.livejournal.com 2006-05-06 01:05 pm (UTC)(link)
I also never really get how much shorter I am than other people until I see pictures or a reflection. I'm not empirically short (the way you are, I must say -- 5'0" I'd call genuinely short, not just quite short, but now that I think about it that's probably because I've internalized the local use of 'quite', which means almost the opposite in British English than it does in the US, omigod I've totally gone native), but I am clearly The Short One in most of my groups of friends, and it never stops being startling to realize that someone I've thought of as shorter than I am is actually the same height, and someone I've thought of as the same height is three inches taller. (This happens all the time. With people I've known for years. My college roommate is like 5'10", 5'11", so she was always The Tall One, and I felt like the rest of us were all sort of together in the world of Shorter Than That; in a cluster, you know, but of similar heights. Yeah. I'm 5'4", and the others are 5'7" and 5'8"-and-a-bit-but-slouches-all-the-time. In short -- hahaha -- if I lost enough weight I'd be small. Oy.)

[identity profile] mearagrrl.livejournal.com 2006-05-04 07:15 pm (UTC)(link)
Yes, though I tend to do this on, well, everyone. But it's very hard, because even if I see someone who is the same "size" as me, they're rarely the same SHAPE. And even if they are, they probably are not my age, or dress in ways I wouldn't. But that said...*I* wear a 14 these days, in many things (occasionally still a 12), but god knows you and I are not the same shape!

[identity profile] kmg-365.livejournal.com 2006-05-04 07:40 pm (UTC)(link)
the average size worn by American women is 14

Which should be further qualified, since a size 14 from Calvin Klein is different from a size 14 from Banana Republic, which is different from a size 14 from the Gap, which is different from...well, you get the idea. ;-)

And no, I'm not a cross-dresser! I buy clothes for my wife all the time. I threw my hands in the air one day, though when she came home from the store one day with a pair of Calvin Klein pants. They fit her nicely, and she said "can you believe the size on this label?"

I looked at it and it was two sizes smaller than what she normally wears (four if you count the non-existant odd numbers).

Sometimes I don't know how women shop for clothes.

[identity profile] darthfox.livejournal.com 2006-05-06 01:08 pm (UTC)(link)
Do you know, it's even more frustrating when men's clothes turn out to be different sizes with the same size labels? (And I'm not a cross-dresser either. [g]) The waist measurement is supposed to be in inches, right? So isn't 30 inches 30 inches no matter what? Yeah, dream on.

That said, it's really a little bit much (back on women's clothes now) that the sizes at Gap and BR and Old Navy aren't the same, since all three are the same company.

[identity profile] kmg-365.livejournal.com 2006-05-08 12:12 pm (UTC)(link)
The waist measurement is supposed to be in inches, right? So isn't 30 inches 30 inches no matter what? Yeah, dream on.


Yeah, I know. Although I find the "all inches are not created equal" rule applies more to the inseam measurement.

[identity profile] tangleofthorns.livejournal.com 2006-05-04 08:06 pm (UTC)(link)
You mean there are women who don't have this experience?

I vary wildly in pants sizes especially. I am wearing a pair of jeans right now that fit rather well from the GAP. I have a pair of jeans that fit quite well that are...something else, LEI or something....that are like three sizes bigger. I'm pretty sure that somebody is lying to me.