fox: my left eye.  "ceci n'est pas une fox." (Default)
fox ([personal profile] fox) wrote2005-05-20 01:06 am
Entry tags:

revenge of the sith

oh. my. GOD.

well, that was superlative.  i'm not quite prepared to say all is forgiven, but certainly this film is Worthy.  i am swoony and light-headed, and it's not because of the slasher-shout-out at the end there.

assorted thoughts:  yea, verily, and mightily i did go "eeeeeeeee!" at multiple other points during the movie as well.  ewan mcgregor is a good-looking man, inn'e?  i was glad they allowed him to smile for once.  sadly, i am not able to think of senator organa by that name; every time i saw him, i thought, "victor sifuentes is fomenting rebellion" or "victor sifuentes is doomed".  oh, the music, the music, LOVE.  oh!  the babies, in the council chamber, i'm glad we didn't see him killing the wee ones, and i'll tell you what, i wish they'd gone ahead and used the word "children" instead of "younglings" at least once; i feel like "younglings" should be a pet name.  the shot of the mask coming down on vader's face was really quite brilliant.

two quibbles:

1.  but, see, whatever you think about the extended (or expanded? i can never remember) universe (what i think:  not canon), or the novelisations (whose brother was owen lars, again?), it is existing film canon, both Correct and Special Edition, that leia has memories of her real mother, who died when she was very small, and that luke never knew her.  an explanation, please, and a plausible one?

2.  "only a sith deals in absolutes."  oh my god, y'all, i'm afraid i laughed out loud.  i wasn't able to control myself.  i laughed for about fifteen seconds.  i mean, seriously.  the irony was coming fast over the plate in this movie, but mainly in a foreshadow-y kind of way, and less in a but-he-just-said-that-with-a-straight-face kind of way.  only a sith deals in absolutes.  i need an icon, stat.
titti: (Default)

[personal profile] titti 2005-05-20 12:55 am (UTC)(link)
Does Leia even know who her real mother is? Or at least did she know until Luke brought it up? Learn to accept grey areas in canon, we must or to the Dark Force we will succumb.